So I took second place in a flash fiction contest, folks. ‘Twas a small one, run by Shock Totem magazine, and the assignment was to write a piece based on the following image.
I had a lovely little idea, explored it in around 500 words, ran it past a few generous critiquers, and sent it in. It was just the way I wanted it, and I wouldn’t change a bit of it.
But here’s the thing: not everybody gets this piece. Even my critiquers didn’t quite catch all of it, the way it was originally written. Sure, once I elucidated for them, they said things like, “Oh! It’s so obvious now you’ve explained it!” But it’s a very oblique, subtle, indirect story.
Exactly the way I intended.
Those who understood the story, loved it. Those who didn’t understand? Here’s a couple of quotes (and believe me, I take none of these personally, they’re used here only as illustration):
“Imply if you want, but imply directly.”
“I love the writing! But what in the hell happened?”
“I think if details had been provided it would have made for a more harrowing tale.”
My beta readers are very intelligent people. I’m also quite sure that those for whom this story didn’t work are intelligent people as well—it’s just my writing didn’t connect with them. I went a bit too far out from the mainstream with this story.
What’s my point? I think it’s this: I have to accept, flat out and right up front, that my writing won’t work for every reader.
Look, you’re never going to please everyone anyway. So why not just write the best story you can, in a way that’s true to your vision and your gut, and send it out into the world to make its way? If people hate it? So what? Let them hate it. You didn’t write it for them. You wrote it because the story clawed its way out of your imagination and sweated itself onto the page. You wrote it for those select people who’ll comprehend it and love it for what it is.
I think we worry too much about people’s potential opinions of our work, writer-friends. Sometimes we just have to write for ourselves—screw the reviews.
After all, that’s how art is made.





