But that wasn’t enough. I had something in my head, see, and I needed to work it out, to get it sorted, to grave the lesson into my neural pathways so that when I’m writing, perhaps struggling with characterization, I have this moment to fall back into, to recollect, to inspire me. I needed to talk it out; I needed another writer. I called one.
We chatted for probably twenty minutes, while I paced my kitchen and gesticulated as though I were suddenly Italian. The realization, the understanding was so powerful, so moving, that I couldn’t let it pass without digging into it, sharing it, feeling it anew.
This is why I read the greats, folks.
Here. Check this passage.
Then, having washed him and covered him with a sheet, she would lie by him in the bed and he would put a brown hand out and touch her and say, “Thou art much woman, Pilar.” It was the nearest to a joke he ever made and then, usually, after the fight, he would go to sleep and she would lie there, holding his hand in her two hands and listening to him breathe.Okay, you may need more context to feel this the way I felt it, but can’t you taste the intimacy? The longing? The complexity of the characters? Can you even glimpse it?
He was often frightened in his sleep and she would feel his hand grip tightly and see the sweat bead on his forehead and if he woke, she said, “It’s nothing,” and he slept again.
I tell you, writer-friends: it’s stunning. It’s nothing short of breathtaking.
Look, I know Hemingway can be spotty. In this same novel, he’s already meandered through several seemingly-unnecessary digressions and political ruminations. But his characterization in For Whom the Bell Tolls, especially in the characters of Pilar, Pablo, and Robert Jordan, is magnificent. What depth he’s infused these people with! What twisted, tortured, pasts! What feeling!
Which, friends, is what it all comes down to. Write literary, write urban fantasy, write erotic comedy, write whatever you want—but by God, make your characters feel something! If they’re not feeling anything, how will your reader?
It’s precisely Pilar’s depth of feeling for the bullfighter Finito—who, incidentally, is merely a tertiary character in the novel, but who’s drawn with such intense clarity that he seems shockingly immediate—that sucks the reader in, that lets us see the man through her eyes, to empathize with her, and with him.
So, yes. This is why I read the great novelists. It’s not so I can sound pretentious when I talk about having read X book by Hemingway or Y book by Faulkner or Z book by Woolf. It’s for moments like I had last night, when the clarity and brilliance of the words transport me, teach me, make me want with every fiber of my being to be a better writer, to reach people the way I know they can be reached if only I can write truly enough.
Above all, I want to feel. And then, if I learn well enough, I can make my reader feel.
That, my friends, is what fiction is for.





